Beyond the Tyranny of Averages: Development Progress from the Bottom Up
Sep 28, 2017
Samantha Custer, Matthew DiLorenzo, Takaaki Masaki, Tanya Sethi, Jessica Wells
Custer, S., DiLorenzo, M., Masaki, T., Sethi, T., & Wells, J. (2017). Beyond the Tyranny of Averages: Development Progress from the Bottom Up. Williamsburg, VA: AidData at William & Mary.
On October 24th, 2017, the AidData-hosted event, Tyranny of Averages: Are we worsening inequality within countries?, brought together Amanda Glassman (CGD), Caroline Heider (World Bank), Selim Jahan (UNDP), Kevin Croke (World Bank), Bradley C. Parks (AidData) and Samantha Custer (AidData) for an engaging panel discussion on issues of inequality and aid targeting addressed by the report. Watch the recording or read a summary of the remarks.
In spite of rising inequality within countries, policymakers often fall into the trap of evaluating progress from the top-down, rather than the bottom-up. Bilateral aid agencies and multilateral development banks tend to use national-level indicators (e.g., GDP per capita, child mortality rates) to select the countries and sectors where they will work. These national aggregates mask hotspots of deprivation within countries, which appear to be widening.
Over the past five years, AidData and its partners have worked with numerous governments and development partners to help close this evidence gap. With generous financial support from the United States Agency for International Development’s Global Development Lab, they have identified the geographical locations of nearly 70,000 development projects worth approximately $1.23 trillion across the globe. As a result, there is now an abundance of geographically disaggregated data we can use to assess: who is funding what, where, and to what effect at the subnational level?
In the Beyond the Tyranny of Averages report, we draw upon this body of work to shed light on two critical questions:
- Targeting — To what extent is the international community channeling resources to the least developed regions within countries?
- Effectiveness — Under which conditions does this assistance help local communities reduce spatial inequality – the uneven distribution of public services, infrastructure, wealth, and opportunity?
Based on our findings, we present a roadmap for countries and their development partners to fully harness the subnational data revolution to "leave no one behind".
Funding: This research was conducted with generous support from the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) Global Development Lab (through cooperative agreement AID-OAA-A-12-00096). The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States Government. This study also supports AidData’s commitments as an anchor partner of the Global Partnership for Sustainable Development Data.
World Bank IBRD-IDA Projects
World Bank Geocoded Research Release, Version 1.4.2
This geocoded dataset includes all projects approved from 1995-2014 in the World Bank IBRD/IDA lending lines. It tracks more than $630 billion in commitments for 5,684 projects across 61,243 locations.
Development projects in Nigeria
Nigeria AIMS Geocoded Research Release, Version 1.3.1
This dataset includes all geocoded projects from Nigeria's Development Assistance Database (DAD). This dataset tracks more than $2.1 billion in commitments for 595 projects across 1,843 locations between 1988 and 2014.
Development projects in Malawi
Malawi Aid Management Platform Geocoded Research Release, 2000-2011
This dataset contains geocoded aid locations from 30 donor agencies in the Malawi Ministry of Finance's Aid Management Platform. The data include US$5.3 billion in commitments, representing approximately 80% of all external funding reported to the Malawi Ministry of Finance since 2000.
Related Blog Posts
Beyond the Tyranny of Averages: AidData report highlights unequal development within countries
Relying on averages is worsening inequality within countries. We look at whether aid financing reaches the poorest regions, and find that donors are missing the mark.
No one left behind: Why we need granular data to respond to hotspots in the U.S. and beyond
The story of why deadly "hotspots" of high lead levels in U.S. neighborhoods went undetected for years, and how data can help address these pockets of inequality.